How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes in Brevard County: A Worksheet and Questions to Ask
If you are buying a home in Brevard County, the homeowners insurance quote is the part of your monthly payment you will probably see last. It can also change what a house really costs by thousands of dollars a year. Use this
worksheet to compare quotes the same way every time, and use the questions below so you know what to ask before your inspection period ends.
Start the quote the day you go under contract
The standard As Is contract gives you 15 days for inspections if nothing else is written in, and an insurance quote can take longer than you would think. Start the day you are under contract. Get at least three quotes, so you can see the
range and not just one number.
The quote worksheet
Fill this out for every quote. Ask each insurance agent to put the same information on one page, so you are comparing the same thing and not two different policies.
1. Company and agent name.
2. Dwelling coverage amount. This is the amount the policy would pay to rebuild the home.
3. The regular deductible, for things like a fire or a leak.
4. The hurricane deductible. It is usually a percentage of the dwelling coverage, commonly 2, 5, or 10 percent. Write
down the percentage and the dollar amount.
5. The yearly premium, and how you would pay it.
6. Discounts included, and which ones the quote counted.
7. Whether the quote used a wind mitigation report, and the price with and without it.
8. Anything the company asked for before it would issue the policy, such as a roof inspection or a four point
inspection.
9. What is not covered. Flood is a separate policy, and your homeowners policy will not cover it.Why the hurricane deductible matters
Most people only see one deductible, and the second one is the one that hurts. On a home insured for 400,000 dollars, a 2 percent hurricane deductible is 8,000 dollars, 5 percent is 20,000 dollars, and 10 percent is 40,000 dollars. A low premium with a 10 percent hurricane deductible is not really a low price. It moves the cost to a day you will really hate. Before you choose, ask yourself whether you could write that check.
Questions to ask the insurance agent
What is the dwelling amount, and how did you set it?
What are the two deductibles, in dollars?
What discounts did you count, and what would I need to do to qualify for more?
What is the price with a wind mitigation report and without one?
Does the roof's age or type change the price or the coverage?
Is there anything you need before you can bind the policy?
What would the monthly payment be if it is paid through my mortgage?
I am a real estate agent and not an insurance agent. Quotes and coverage advice should come from a licensed insurance agent.
Questions to ask the seller
How old is the roof, and what is it made of?
Are there permits for the roof, the windows, or any major work?
Is there a wind mitigation report, and is it still good? These reports are generally good for five years.
Has the home had any insurance claims, and when?
Has the seller had a four point inspection done recently?
What does the seller pay for insurance now? It will not be your price, but it gives you a starting point.
What moves the price the most
Four things move the price more than anything else. The first is the roof, its age and its type. The second is the year the house was built. The third is features that make the home stronger in a storm. The fourth is the claims history of the property. Where the home sits matters too. The closer you are to the water, the more wind risk the company is pricing, and the price follows the risk.
From my own clients, not a published rate, I see about $5,000 to $9,000 a year on the water in Brevard County and about $1,000 to $5,000 on the mainland. Your house will land where it lands, which is why one blended number
never fits anybody. Get the quote on the home you are actually looking at.
What about the roof
Under Florida law, an insurer cannot refuse to cover a home solely because of the roof's age if that roof is under 15 years old. Older than that, you may be asked for an inspection, and a roof with five or more years of life left cannot
be turned down on age alone. Insurers can still say no for other reasons, so ask early. Some companies also set their own roof age limits, and they are not the same everywhere.
The wind mitigation inspection
A wind mitigation inspection usually costs somewhere around 75 to 150 dollars and takes about an hour. The inspector looks at how the roof is attached, the roof shape, whether there is a water barrier under the roofing, and whether every window and door is protected. Florida law says insurers have to offer discounts for features that reduce hurricane damage. I cannot tell you what your discount will be, so ask for a quote with the report and
without it, then compare. Ask the seller first, since they may already have one that is still good. If you apply for Citizens on a new purchase, they can
turn you away when a private company offers coverage that is no more than 20% above the Citizens price. Get the private quotes first.
What the rate news does and does not mean
On September 22, Florida's insurance regulator approved four homeowner rate decreases averaging about 7%, covering about 62,000 policies. Citizens was down to about 266,000 policies as of August, from 1.4 million
in 2023. The state has said it expects more cuts. That is real news, but those are averages across thousands of policies. They are not your quote, and nobody can promise where rates go next. Shop the number in front of you.
Common questions
When should I get an insurance quote when buying a home in Florida?
As soon as you are under contract, and before your inspection period ends. Starting early gives you time to compare at least three quotes.
Is homeowners insurance cheaper on the mainland than on the water in Brevard County? In my clients' experience, usually yes. About $1,000 to $5,000 a year on the mainland and about $5,000 to $9,000 on the water. These are my observations, not a published rate.
Does homeowners insurance cover flood?
No. Flood is a separate policy. What is a wind mitigation inspection?
An inspection of the features that help a home resist hurricane winds, such as how the roof is attached and whether windows and doors are protected. It can lower your premium.
Want help working through it?
If you are buying in Brevard County and want your insurance numbers before you make an offer, call or text me, or visit crystalsells321.com. You do not have to figure this out alone.
Sources: Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, September 22, 2026 rate announcement. Citizens Property Insurance policy counts as reported by Insurance Journal. Florida statutes on roof age and wind mitigation discounts. The dollar examples for hurricane deductibles are math on a made up home, not a quote for any property. This is general information and not insurance or legal advice.




Comments